Results: The wealthy should pay a higher rate of tax than everyone else

#	For	Against	Judge	Scores	Result	Link
1	🏆 Susan (gemma2:9b)	Ingrid (mistral:7b)	Pat (llama3.1:8b)	Ingrid: 8 · Susan: 9	Upheld	View →
2	Kezia (mistral:7b)	🏆 Marcus (llama3.1:8b)	Richard (qwen2.5:7b)	Kezia: 8 · Marcus: 6	Rejected	View →
3	🏆 Kezia (qwen2.5:7b)	Tom (llama3.1:8b)	Richard (gemma2:9b)	Kezia: 8 · Tom: 6	Upheld	View →
4	Kezia (mistral:7b)	🏆 Marcus (mistral:7b)	Pat (mistral:7b)	Marcus: 8 · Kezia: 6	Rejected	View →
5	🏆 Prof. Aisha (llama3.1:8b)	Tom (llama3.1:8b)	Claire (qwen2.5:7b)	Prof. Aisha: 8 · Tom: 6	Upheld	View →
6	🏆 Susan (gemma2:9b)	Tom (mistral:7b)	Claire (qwen2.5:7b)	Tom: 8 · Susan: 6	Upheld	View →
7	🏆 Susan (qwen2.5:7b)	Tom (llama3.1:8b)	Pat (mistral:7b)	Susan: 8 · Tom: 6	Upheld	View →
8	Susan (qwen2.5:7b)	🏆 Marcus (gemma2:9b)	Richard (qwen2.5:7b)	Susan: 8 · Marcus: 6	Rejected	View →
9	Susan (mistral:7b)	🏆 Ingrid (mistral:7b)	Richard (mistral:7b)	Ingrid: 8 · Susan: 6	Rejected	View →
10	🏆 Susan (llama3.1:8b)	Marcus (qwen2.5:7b)	Claire (gemma2:9b)	Marcus: 4 · Susan: 8	Upheld	View →
11	🏆 Susan (qwen2.5:7b)	Ingrid (mistral:7b)	Richard (llama3.1:8b)	Ingrid: 8 · Susan: 6	Upheld	View →
12	🏆 Prof. Aisha (llama3.1:8b)	Tom (llama3.1:8b)	Richard (qwen2.5:7b)	Tom: 6 · Prof. Aisha: 9	Upheld	View →
13	🏆 Susan (gemma2:9b)	Marcus (llama3.1:8b)	Richard (qwen2.5:7b)	Susan: 8 · Marcus: 6	Upheld	View →
14	Susan (llama3.1:8b)	🏆 Ingrid (qwen2.5:7b)	Richard (gemma2:9b)	Susan: 7 · Ingrid: 8	Rejected	View →
15	🏆 Prof. Aisha (gemma2:9b)	Marcus (llama3.1:8b)	Pat (llama3.1:8b)	Marcus: 6 · Prof. Aisha: 9	Upheld	View →
16	🏆 Prof. Aisha (mistral:7b)	Marcus (llama3.1:8b)	Richard (mistral:7b)	Prof. Aisha: 8 · Marcus: 6	Upheld	View →
17	Kezia (gemma2:9b)	🏆 Tom (llama3.1:8b)	Pat (qwen2.5:7b)	Tom: 8 · Kezia: 6	Rejected	View →
18	🏆 Prof. Aisha (gemma2:9b)	Marcus (llama3.1:8b)	Claire (mistral:7b)	Marcus: 6 · Prof. Aisha: 8	Upheld	View →
19	🏆 Susan (mistral:7b)	Marcus (qwen2.5:7b)	Richard (mistral:7b)	Marcus: 6 · Susan: 8	Upheld	View →
20	🏆 Susan (llama3.1:8b)	Marcus (mistral:7b)	Pat (qwen2.5:7b)	Marcus: 8 · Susan: 6	Upheld	View →
21	🏆 Susan (gemma2:9b)	Ingrid (llama3.1:8b)	Richard (qwen2.5:7b)	Susan: 8 · Ingrid: 6	Upheld	View →
22	🏆 Susan (gemma2:9b)	Marcus (mistral:7b)	Richard (gemma2:9b)	Marcus: 4 · Susan: 9	Upheld	View →
23	🏆 Susan (mistral:7b)	Ingrid (qwen2.5:7b)	Pat (llama3.1:8b)	Ingrid: 4 · Susan: 9	Upheld	View →
24	Susan (qwen2.5:7b)	🏆 Marcus (mistral:7b)	Claire (mistral:7b)	Marcus: 8 · Susan: 6	Rejected	View →
25	🏆 Kezia (mistral:7b)	Tom (qwen2.5:7b)	Pat (llama3.1:8b)	Kezia: 8 · Tom: 6	Upheld	View →
26	🏆 Kezia (qwen2.5:7b)	Tom (mistral:7b)	Claire (mistral:7b)	Tom: 6 · Kezia: 8	Upheld	View →
27	🏆 Prof. Aisha (llama3.1:8b)	Tom (mistral:7b)	Pat (qwen2.5:7b)	Tom: 8 · Prof. Aisha: 6	Upheld	View →
28	🏆 Susan (llama3.1:8b)	Ingrid (mistral:7b)	Claire (gemma2:9b)	Ingrid: 4 · Susan: 8	Upheld	View →
29	🏆 Prof. Aisha (qwen2.5:7b)	Ingrid (mistral:7b)	Claire (llama3.1:8b)	Prof. Aisha: 8 · Ingrid: 6	Upheld	View →
30	🏆 Prof. Aisha (qwen2.5:7b)	Marcus (mistral:7b)	Claire (gemma2:9b)	Marcus: 4 · Prof. Aisha: 8	Upheld	View →
31	Prof. Aisha (qwen2.5:7b)	🏆 Ingrid (llama3.1:8b)	Claire (llama3.1:8b)	Prof. Aisha: 6 · Ingrid: 9	Rejected	View →
32	🏆 Prof. Aisha (gemma2:9b)	Ingrid (gemma2:9b)	Claire (llama3.1:8b)	Prof. Aisha: 9 · Ingrid: 7	Upheld	View →
33	🏆 Susan (llama3.1:8b)	Marcus (mistral:7b)	Richard (gemma2:9b)	Susan: 8 · Marcus: 3	Upheld	View →
34	Prof. Aisha (mistral:7b)	🏆 Ingrid (qwen2.5:7b)	Claire (mistral:7b)	Ingrid: 8 · Prof. Aisha: 6	Rejected	View →
35	Susan (qwen2.5:7b)	🏆 Marcus (llama3.1:8b)	Pat (llama3.1:8b)	Susan: 8 · Marcus: 9	Rejected	View →
36	Prof. Aisha (mistral:7b)	🏆 Tom (llama3.1:8b)	Richard (gemma2:9b)	Prof. Aisha: 6 · Tom: 8	Rejected	View →
37	🏆 Kezia (llama3.1:8b)	Ingrid (llama3.1:8b)	Claire (llama3.1:8b)	Kezia: 8 · Ingrid: 6	Upheld	View →
38	🏆 Susan (qwen2.5:7b)	Ingrid (llama3.1:8b)	Claire (gemma2:9b)	Ingrid: 6 · Susan: 8	Upheld	View →
39	🏆 Kezia (llama3.1:8b)	Ingrid (mistral:7b)	Claire (mistral:7b)	Kezia: 8 · Ingrid: 6	Upheld	View →
40	🏆 Kezia (llama3.1:8b)	Tom (qwen2.5:7b)	Claire (qwen2.5:7b)	Kezia: 8 · Tom: 6	Upheld	View →
41	Kezia (mistral:7b)	🏆 Ingrid (gemma2:9b)	Richard (gemma2:9b)	Kezia: 4 · Ingrid: 8	Rejected	View →
42	🏆 Prof. Aisha (qwen2.5:7b)	Tom (llama3.1:8b)	Claire (gemma2:9b)	Prof. Aisha: 8 · Tom: 6	Upheld	View →
43	🏆 Prof. Aisha (gemma2:9b)	Tom (gemma2:9b)	Claire (qwen2.5:7b)	Tom: 8 · Prof. Aisha: 6	Upheld	View →
44	🏆 Prof. Aisha (mistral:7b)	Marcus (qwen2.5:7b)	Pat (mistral:7b)	Marcus: 6 · Prof. Aisha: 8	Upheld	View →
45	🏆 Kezia (qwen2.5:7b)	Marcus (qwen2.5:7b)	Pat (qwen2.5:7b)	Kezia: 8 · Marcus: 6	Upheld	View →
46	Kezia (qwen2.5:7b)	🏆 Ingrid (mistral:7b)	Claire (mistral:7b)	Ingrid: 8 · Kezia: 6	Rejected	View →
47	🏆 Susan (llama3.1:8b)	Tom (qwen2.5:7b)	Claire (qwen2.5:7b)	Susan: 8 · Tom: 6	Upheld	View →
48	🏆 Kezia (qwen2.5:7b)	Marcus (gemma2:9b)	Pat (llama3.1:8b)	Marcus: 5 · Kezia: 8	Upheld	View →
49	Kezia (mistral:7b)	🏆 Marcus (llama3.1:8b)	Pat (llama3.1:8b)	Kezia: 5 · Marcus: 9	Rejected	View →
50	🏆 Susan (llama3.1:8b)	Tom (llama3.1:8b)	Claire (qwen2.5:7b)	Tom: 8 · Susan: 6	Upheld	View →
51	Kezia (mistral:7b)	🏆 Marcus (llama3.1:8b)	Pat (mistral:7b)	Marcus: 8 · Kezia: 6	Rejected	View →
52	🏆 Kezia (llama3.1:8b)	Ingrid (mistral:7b)	Pat (mistral:7b)	Kezia: 8 · Ingrid: 6	Upheld	View →
53	🏆 Susan (llama3.1:8b)	Tom (qwen2.5:7b)	Pat (gemma2:9b)	Susan: 8 · Tom: 6	Upheld	View →
54	🏆 Kezia (gemma2:9b)	Marcus (llama3.1:8b)	Richard (qwen2.5:7b)	Kezia: 8 · Marcus: 6	Upheld	View →
55	🏆 Susan (mistral:7b)	Tom (gemma2:9b)	Claire (mistral:7b)	Tom: 5 · Susan: 8	Upheld	View →
56	🏆 Susan (llama3.1:8b)	Tom (mistral:7b)	Claire (mistral:7b)	Tom: 6 · Susan: 8	Upheld	View →
57	🏆 Kezia (qwen2.5:7b)	Marcus (gemma2:9b)	Richard (gemma2:9b)	Kezia: 8 · Marcus: 3	Upheld	View →
58	Susan (qwen2.5:7b)	🏆 Tom (qwen2.5:7b)	Pat (gemma2:9b)	Susan: 6 · Tom: 8	Rejected	View →
59	Kezia (gemma2:9b)	🏆 Ingrid (llama3.1:8b)	Richard (gemma2:9b)	Kezia: 7 · Ingrid: 8	Rejected	View →
60	🏆 Susan (llama3.1:8b)	Marcus (gemma2:9b)	Claire (qwen2.5:7b)	Susan: 8 · Marcus: 6	Upheld	View →
61	🏆 Kezia (llama3.1:8b)	Ingrid (qwen2.5:7b)	Claire (llama3.1:8b)	Kezia: 9 · Ingrid: 6	Upheld	View →
62	🏆 Susan (llama3.1:8b)	Tom (qwen2.5:7b)	Richard (gemma2:9b)	Tom: 5 · Susan: 8	Upheld	View →
63	🏆 Prof. Aisha (qwen2.5:7b)	Tom (llama3.1:8b)	Claire (qwen2.5:7b)	Prof. Aisha: 8 · Tom: 6	Upheld	View →
64	Susan (mistral:7b)	🏆 Marcus (gemma2:9b)	Pat (gemma2:9b)	Susan: 6 · Marcus: 7	Rejected	View →
65	🏆 Prof. Aisha (llama3.1:8b)	Marcus (llama3.1:8b)	Richard (gemma2:9b)	Prof. Aisha: 8 · Marcus: 6	Upheld	View →
66	🏆 Susan (qwen2.5:7b)	Tom (qwen2.5:7b)	Claire (llama3.1:8b)	Susan: 9 · Tom: 6	Upheld	View →
67	🏆 Kezia (llama3.1:8b)	Marcus (qwen2.5:7b)	Richard (llama3.1:8b)	Kezia: 8 · Marcus: 6	Upheld	View →
68	🏆 Susan (gemma2:9b)	Tom (gemma2:9b)	Claire (llama3.1:8b)	Tom: 6 · Susan: 9	Upheld	View →
69	Prof. Aisha (mistral:7b)	🏆 Ingrid (llama3.1:8b)	Richard (gemma2:9b)	Prof. Aisha: 6 · Ingrid: 8	Rejected	View →
70	Prof. Aisha (qwen2.5:7b)	🏆 Marcus (gemma2:9b)	Claire (qwen2.5:7b)	Marcus: 8 · Prof. Aisha: 6	Rejected	View →
71	🏆 Kezia (mistral:7b)	Marcus (gemma2:9b)	Claire (gemma2:9b)	Kezia: 8 · Marcus: 6	Upheld	View →
72	🏆 Susan (llama3.1:8b)	Tom (mistral:7b)	Richard (mistral:7b)	Susan: 8 · Tom: 6	Upheld	View →
73	🏆 Susan (mistral:7b)	Ingrid (mistral:7b)	Claire (mistral:7b)	Susan: 8 · Ingrid: 6	Upheld	View →
74	🏆 Prof. Aisha (mistral:7b)	Tom (gemma2:9b)	Richard (gemma2:9b)	Prof. Aisha: 6 · Tom: 3	Upheld	View →
75	🏆 Prof. Aisha (mistral:7b)	Marcus (gemma2:9b)	Pat (gemma2:9b)	Marcus: 6 · Prof. Aisha: 9	Upheld	View →
76	Kezia (mistral:7b)	🏆 Ingrid (mistral:7b)	Pat (gemma2:9b)	Kezia: 7 · Ingrid: 8	Rejected	View →
77	🏆 Susan (gemma2:9b)	Ingrid (qwen2.5:7b)	Claire (mistral:7b)	Susan: 8 · Ingrid: 6	Upheld	View →
78	Prof. Aisha (mistral:7b)	🏆 Ingrid (llama3.1:8b)	Pat (gemma2:9b)	Prof. Aisha: 6 · Ingrid: 8	Rejected	View →
79	Kezia (qwen2.5:7b)	🏆 Ingrid (llama3.1:8b)	Claire (qwen2.5:7b)	Ingrid: 8 · Kezia: 6	Rejected	View →
80	🏆 Susan (gemma2:9b)	Ingrid (gemma2:9b)	Claire (llama3.1:8b)	Ingrid: 5 · Susan: 9	Upheld	View →
81	🏆 Prof. Aisha (llama3.1:8b)	Marcus (gemma2:9b)	Pat (qwen2.5:7b)	Prof. Aisha: 8 · Marcus: 6	Upheld	View →
82	🏆 Kezia (mistral:7b)	Ingrid (mistral:7b)	Claire (gemma2:9b)	Ingrid: 6 · Kezia: 8	Upheld	View →
83	🏆 Susan (llama3.1:8b)	Marcus (qwen2.5:7b)	Claire (mistral:7b)	Marcus: 6 · Susan: 8	Upheld	View →
84	🏆 Susan (mistral:7b)	Tom (mistral:7b)	Richard (mistral:7b)	Susan: 8 · Tom: 6	Upheld	View →
85	🏆 Prof. Aisha (gemma2:9b)	Marcus (qwen2.5:7b)	Claire (mistral:7b)	Prof. Aisha: 8 · Marcus: 6	Upheld	View →
86	🏆 Susan (llama3.1:8b)	Tom (qwen2.5:7b)	Claire (qwen2.5:7b)	Susan: 8 · Tom: 6	Upheld	View →
87	🏆 Kezia (qwen2.5:7b)	Tom (llama3.1:8b)	Pat (qwen2.5:7b)	Tom: 8 · Kezia: 6	Upheld	View →
88	🏆 Prof. Aisha (llama3.1:8b)	Marcus (gemma2:9b)	Richard (qwen2.5:7b)	Marcus: 8 · Prof. Aisha: 6	Upheld	View →
89	Kezia (qwen2.5:7b)	🏆 Ingrid (mistral:7b)	Claire (mistral:7b)	Kezia: 8 · Ingrid: 7	Rejected	View →
90	🏆 Prof. Aisha (mistral:7b)	Ingrid (gemma2:9b)	Claire (gemma2:9b)	Ingrid: 7 · Prof. Aisha: 9	Upheld	View →
91	Susan (gemma2:9b)	🏆 Ingrid (llama3.1:8b)	Claire (gemma2:9b)	Ingrid: 8 · Susan: 6	Rejected	View →
92	🏆 Kezia (llama3.1:8b)	Tom (mistral:7b)	Claire (qwen2.5:7b)	Kezia: 8 · Tom: 6	Upheld	View →
93	🏆 Susan (gemma2:9b)	Tom (llama3.1:8b)	Claire (gemma2:9b)	Tom: 5 · Susan: 9	Upheld	View →
94	🏆 Kezia (qwen2.5:7b)	Marcus (llama3.1:8b)	Claire (llama3.1:8b)	Marcus: 7 · Kezia: 9	Upheld	View →
95	Susan (qwen2.5:7b)	🏆 Tom (qwen2.5:7b)	Richard (mistral:7b)	Tom: 8 · Susan: 6	Rejected	View →
96	🏆 Prof. Aisha (gemma2:9b)	Marcus (llama3.1:8b)	Pat (llama3.1:8b)	Prof. Aisha: 8 · Marcus: 6	Upheld	View →
97	Prof. Aisha (mistral:7b)	🏆 Ingrid (gemma2:9b)	Pat (qwen2.5:7b)	Ingrid: 8 · Prof. Aisha: 6	Rejected	View →
98	🏆 Prof. Aisha (gemma2:9b)	Marcus (mistral:7b)	Pat (llama3.1:8b)	Marcus: 6 · Prof. Aisha: 9	Upheld	View →
99	🏆 Kezia (mistral:7b)	Marcus (mistral:7b)	Claire (qwen2.5:7b)	Marcus: 6 · Kezia: 8	Upheld	View →
100	🏆 Susan (mistral:7b)	Tom (mistral:7b)	Claire (llama3.1:8b)	Susan: 9 · Tom: 6	Upheld	View →

100 Runs

73 Premise Upheld

27 Premise Rejected

73% Uphold Rate

Debater Performance

Name	Side	n	Wins	Win%	Avg score
Susan	for	41	32	78%	7.7
Prof. Aisha	for	29	22	76%	7.4
Kezia	for	30	19	63%	7.4
Ingrid	against	31	14	45%	6.9
Marcus	against	37	9	24%	6.2
Tom	against	32	4	12%	6.4

Judge Profile

Name	n	Upheld	Rejected	Uphold%	Bias
Claire	46	38	8	83%	+10%
Pat	27	17	10	63%	-10%
Richard	27	18	9	67%	-6%

Speaking Order (n=100)

Position	Wins	Win%
First speaker	50	50%
Second speaker	50	50%

Side Effect (n=100)

Side	Wins	Win%
For	73	73%
Against	27	27%

Model Performance (Debater)

Model	n	Wins	Win%	Avg score
llama3.1:8b	59	38	64%	7.3
gemma2:9b	39	22	56%	7.1
qwen2.5:7b	46	19	41%	6.8
mistral:7b	56	21	38%	6.8

Model Performance (Judge)

Model	n	Upheld	Rejected	Uphold%	Bias
gemma2:9b	28	18	10	64%	-9%
qwen2.5:7b	27	21	6	78%	+5%
mistral:7b	24	16	8	67%	-6%
llama3.1:8b	21	18	3	86%	+13%

This page summarises the results of a simulated debate. For each round, two random AI agents debate a topic; at the end a third agent acts as judge to select a winner. All arguments and facts presented (with the exception of this paragraph) are AI-generated, potentially untrue, and do not represent the views of any real person.